
Defense of the dissertation of Karakozhayeva Aliya for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in the specialty «6D051700 - Innovative Management»
L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University, a dissertation defense for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) by Karakozhayeva Aliya on the topic «Formation and Development of Innovative Competencies of Human Capital in the Republic of Kazakhstan» by specialty «6D051700 – Innovative Management».
The dissertation was carried out at the «Management education department» of L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University.
The language of defense is kazakh
Official reviewers:
Sabirova Rysty Kuandikovna – Candidate of Economic Sciences, Professor, Kh. Dosmukhamedov Atyrau University (Atyrau, Republic of Kazakhstan).
Tamenova Saltanat Sarsenbayevna – Candidate of Economic Sciences, Associate Professor, Turan University (Almaty, Republic of Kazakhstan).
Temporary members of the Dissertation Committee:
Kerimkulova Merimkul Kadyrovna – Candidate of Economic Sciences, Professor, Director of the Institute of Management and Business at Kyrgyz National University named after J. Balasagyn (Bishkek, Kyrgyz Republic).
Bakirbekova Aigul Makulbekovna – Candidate of Economic Sciences, Associate Professor at the Department of Management and Agribusiness Organization, Kazakh National Agrarian Research University (Almaty, Republic of Kazakhstan).
Rakhimbekova Assel Ermekovna – Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), Associate Professor, Director of the Department of Strategy and International Relations at JSC «National Center for Professional Development» (Astana, Republic of Kazakhstan).
Scientific advisors:
Baurzhan Issabekov – Doctor of Economic Sciences, Professor (Astana, Republic of Kazakhstan);
Alla Pranevich – Doctor of Economic Sciences, Professor at the Department of World Economy, Belarusian State Economic University. (Minsk, Belarus).
The defense will take place on December 28, 2026, at 02:00 PM in the Dissertation Council for the training direction «8D041 – Business and administration» in the specialty «6D051700 – Innovative Management» of L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University. The defense meeting is planned to be held offline and online.
Link: https://teams.microsoft.com/meet/433651850984941?p=sD6Wbed4e37hz7MjiX
Address: Astana, Kazhymukan str. 11, Educational and Laboratorial building, auditorium No. 518.
Abstract (English): the dissertation by Aliya Muratbekkyzy Karakozhayeva entitled “Formation and Development of Innovative Competencies of Human Capital in the Republic of Kazakhstan”, submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in the specialty “6D051700 – Innovation Management”. Relevance of the research Topic. In the context of Industry 4.0, the development of human capital and the formation of its innovative competencies are important factors in enhancing economic competitiveness and adapting to technological changes. The rapid advancement of digitalization, automation, and artificial intelligence places new demands on the workforce, increasing the importance of creativity, critical thinking, emotional intelligence, and digital competencies. In Kazakhstan, the relevance of this issue is driven by a shortage of qualified specialists and the need to develop the innovative potential of human capital. At the same time, the insufficient development of theoretical and methodological approaches to defining the structure of innovative competencies, assessing their relationship with human capital, and designing mechanisms for their development highlights the need for comprehensive research and the development of a scientifically grounded model adapted to the conditions of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The object of the dissertation research is the human capital of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the context of Industry 4.0. The subject of the dissertation research is the factors, processes, and management mechanisms influencing the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital in the Republic of Kazakhstan in the context of Industry 4.0. The purpose of the dissertation research is to advance the theoretical and methodological foundations for the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital in the Republic of Kazakhstan in the context of Industry 4.0, to develop a conceptual model, and to formulate practical recommendations. Based on the stated aim, the following research objectives were formulated and achieved: 1. To systematize the theoretical and methodological foundations of innovative competencies of human capital and to define their content and structure. 2. To develop a conceptual model for the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital and to substantiate its structural components and causal relationships. 3. To conduct a comparative analysis of advanced international practices in the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital and to identify opportunities for their adaptation to the context of Kazakhstan. 4. To conduct a comprehensive assessment of the current state of human capital in the Republic of Kazakhstan and to identify trends in its development. 5. To empirically assess the impact of innovative competencies on human capital and the influence of human capital on adaptation to the requirements of Industry 4.0 in the Republic of Kazakhstan using Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM). 6. To evaluate the level of implementation of management mechanisms for the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital in the Republic of Kazakhstan. 7. To identify the key directions for managing the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital in the context of Industry 4.0 and to develop practical recommendations. Degree of Scientific Development of the Research Topic. Significant contributions to the formation and development of human capital theory have been made by T. Schultz, G. Becker, J. Mincer, B. Chiswick, C. Goldin, L. Katz, and other scholars. Their works examine the nature of human capital as an economic resource and the impact of investments in education and professional skills on labor productivity, economic growth, and innovative development. Issues related to human capital development have been addressed in the works of Kazakhstani scholars Yu. K. Shokamanov, A. G. Mukhamedzhanova, A. B. Maidyrova, and B. N. Issabekov. The theoretical foundations of innovation are presented in the studies of J. Schumpeter, Sledzik, and Moreiro, while the theoretical and methodological foundations of the competency-based approach have been developed in the works of D. McClelland, R. Boyatzis, L. and S. Spencer, F. Delamare Le Deist, J. Winterton, Sanghi, and Velde. The characteristics and interrelationships of professional, social, personal, and meta-competencies have been analyzed in the studies of Cheetham, Chivers, D. Goleman, R. Boyatzis, Woodcock, Francis, and Baležentis. The theoretical and applied aspects of innovative competencies have been examined in the works of Jussila, Watts (INCODE), Hero, Pérez-Peñalver, Ovbiagbonhia, Akimova, Chen, Mikolajczak, and Li-Li Ma, highlighting their role in generating new ideas, implementing technologies, and adapting to the conditions of Industry 4.0. Individual components of innovative competencies have been explored by the following researchers: artificial intelligence competencies – Bru-Luna, Dumitriu, Mehta, S. Lee, and Akimova; emotional intelligence – Alabbasi, van Laar, Hughes, and Nicola; creativity – Jussila, Watts, Hero, and Chen; and critical thinking – Facione, Elder, Paul, Hulks, Reibold, Kokebayeva, and Kartabayeva. These studies substantiate the importance of innovative competencies in human capital development and provide a theoretical and methodological foundation for their comprehensive assessment and formation. The theoretical and methodological framework of the research are based on the results of a systematic analysis of scientific publications indexed in the international Scopus and Web of Science databases for the period 2007–2024. The research is grounded in the principles of human capital theory and innovation theory. The theoretical foundation draws on the ideas of T. Schultz and G. Becker, who conceptualize human capital as the result of investments in education, skills, and abilities, as well as J. Schumpeter’s concept of innovation-driven development, which considers innovation a key driver of economic growth and structural change. In the empirical part of the research, Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) was employed using SmartPLS software to assess causal relationships between variables and to test the proposed theoretical model. The information base of the research consists of primary and secondary data. The primary data were obtained from a survey of 1,447 residents of Kazakhstan aged 18–63, conducted in September–October 2025. The secondary data were drawn from materials published by the Bureau of National Statistics of the Republic of Kazakhstan, official government documents, reports and databases of the World Bank, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), the United Nations (UN), and other national and international organizations. Scientific Novelty of the Research consists of the following: 1. An original scientific definition of the concept of “Innovative Competencies of Human Capital” has been proposed. 2. An original conceptual model integrating the innovative competencies of human capital (artificial intelligence competencies, emotional intelligence, creativity, and critical thinking) has been developed, and the mechanism of their interaction has been identified. 3. For the first time, an empirical assessment of the influence of factors determining the formation of innovative competencies of human capital in the Republic of Kazakhstan has been conducted using Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM). 4. Scientifically grounded practical recommendations for developing innovative competencies of human capital in the context of Industry 4.0 have been formulated, and the potential for their application in improving the education system and developing the labor market has been substantiated. 5. A multidisciplinary study has been conducted, integrating approaches from human capital economics, innovation theory, knowledge management, and educational sciences. Main Provisions Submitted for Defense: 1. An original definition of the concept of “Innovative Competencies of Human Capital”. 2. A conceptual research model for the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital. 3. A structural model describing the impact of innovative competencies on human capital and the influence of human capital on adaptation to the requirements of Industry 4.0 in the Republic of Kazakhstan. 4. The results of an assessment of the level of implementation of managerial and governmental mechanisms aimed at the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital in the Republic of Kazakhstan. 5. Key directions for managing the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital in the context of Industry 4.0, as well as practice-oriented recommendations aimed at enhancing the adaptability and innovative potential of the economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Theoretical Significance of the Research. This study extends the classical theory of human capital developed by T. Schultz and G. Becker by demonstrating that, in the context of Industry 4.0, investments in intangible and behavioral competencies have a significant impact on human capital development and its adaptation to the conditions of the modern economy. Thus, the research contributes to classical human capital theories and contemporary models of innovative competencies by substantiating the need for comprehensive and interdisciplinary approaches to human capital development in the context of the digital transformation of the economy. Practical Significance of the Research. The research findings demonstrate that thedevelopment of innovative competencies, such as creativity, emotional intelligence, critical thinking, and artificial intelligence skills, significantly contributes to strengthening human capital and enhancing its readiness for change. These findings served as the basis for developing practical recommendations for the education sector and the private sector of the economy. In particular, in the education sector, the proposed approaches include the development of teachers’ critical thinking through a coaching approach, an original career guidance board game designed to enhance school students’ understanding of innovative competencies and support their career choices, and an original methodological product (teaching guide) aimed at developing innovative competencies. These approaches enable the comprehensive development of not only technical skills but also creative thinking, emotional awareness, and critical reasoning abilities among learners. In the private sector of the economy, methodological recommendations have been developed for Human Resource Management (HRM) specialists to promote the development of innovative competencies. These recommendations propose incorporating creativity and emotional intelligence as key criteria in employee recruitment, assessment, and development practices within organizations undergoing digital transformation. The dissertation research was conducted within the framework of grant funding under the “Zhas Galym” (“Young Scientist”) project, pursuant to Agreement No. 52ЖҒ-25–27 dated February 27, 2025, under the priority research area “Intellectual Potential of the Nation,” as part of the postdoctoral research project AP25795021, entitled “Development of Teachers’ Meta-competencies in Kazakhstan through a Coaching Approach: Assessment and Future Directions.” The career guidance board game “KәсібиGO: ойна да таңда” (“Play and Choose”) was developed within the framework of the “Tauelsizdik Urpaktary – 2024” (“Generation of Independence – 2024”) grant project. The implementation of the project was planned through the “Orleu” National Center for Professional Development. The following results were achieved during the research: 1. The theoretical and methodological foundations of innovative competencies of human capital were systematized, an original definition of the concept of “innovative competencies” was proposed, and their content and structure were identified. 2. A multilevel conceptual model for the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital was developed, and its key components and interrelationships were substantiated. 3. A comparative analysis of the experiences of Singapore, Finland, and the United States was conducted, and opportunities for adapting advanced approaches to innovative competency development to the context of Kazakhstan were identified. 4. A comprehensive assessment of the current state of human capital in Kazakhstan was conducted, identifying major challenges related to regional disparities, migration, insufficient funding for research and development (R&D), and the condition of educational infrastructure. 5. Using Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM), the impact of innovative competencies on human capital was empirically confirmed: creativity (β = 0.333), emotional intelligence (β = 0.241), artificial intelligence competencies (β = 0.135), and critical thinking (β = 0.129). The effect of human capital on adaptation to Industry 4.0 was β = 0.650. All five research hypotheses were supported (p < 0.001). 6. An assessment of the existing management mechanisms for developing innovative competencies in Kazakhstan was conducted, and directions for their improvement at the educational, organisational, and governmental levels were identified. 7. Practical recommendations for developing innovative competencies were formulated, including the “KәсібиGO: ойна да таңда” (“Play and Choose”) board game, the book “Skills. Skills Are More Important Than Knowledge...”, methodological recommendations in Human Resource Management (HRM), the Research Skills initiative, and solutions for developing teachers’ meta-competencies. The potential effects of their implementation, estimated using the model, were assessed at up to 0.419 standard deviation units for human capital and up to 0.272 standard deviation units for readiness for Industry 4.0. Approbation of the Research Results. The dissertation's main provisions and findings were presented and discussed at international scientific and practical conferences held in Ukraine, Belarus, and Kyrgyzstan. The practical results of the research have been implemented in educational and organizational management activities. Original methodological materials and practical recommendations aimed at the formation and development of innovative competencies of human capital have been developed. Supporting documents confirming the implementation of the research results are available. Publications. The main findings of the dissertation research have been published in 9 scientific works, including: 1 (one) article in the international scientific journal Problems and Perspectives in Management, indexed in the Scopus database (76th percentile in the “Social Sciences (miscellaneous)” category and 53rd percentile in the “Business, Management and Accounting” category); 5 (five) articles in scientific journals recommended by the Committee for Quality Assurance in Science and Higher Education of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan; and 3 (three) articles in the proceedings of international scientific and practical conferences. In addition, 2 (two) certificates of state registration of copyright were obtained from the National Institute of Intellectual Property of the Republic of Kazakhstan (Kazpatent): No. 48053 dated July 1, 2024, and No. 57143 dated April 24, 2025. Structure of the Dissertation. The dissertation consists of an introduction, three chapters, a conclusion, a list of references, and appendices. The dissertation comprises 151 pages, including 32 tables and 22 figures. The reference list contains 232 sources.
