
International Experience in Constitutional Proceedings: Open Class Conducted by an ENU Doctoral Student

On October 30, 2026, Murat Ospanov, a second-year doctoral student in the 8D04201 Law programme, conducted an open class in “Comparative Constitutional Procedural Law” on the topic “Judicial Management of Hearings, Resolution of Motions, and Procedures for Judicial Recusal in Constitutional Proceedings.”
The class was held as part of his teaching practice under the supervision of Professor E.B. Abdrassulov, Director of the Institute of Constitutionalism and Digital Law.
The class covered the principles of fair proceedings, procedural safeguards, judicial powers, and procedures for resolving motions and recusal requests. Particular attention was paid to a comparative analysis of constitutional justice in Kazakhstan, Germany, France, the United States, and CIS countries.
The practical session was conducted as a role-playing exercise in which students simulated a Constitutional Court hearing. Participants assumed different procedural roles, submitted motions and recusal requests, presented legal arguments, and made procedural decisions.
The class contributed to the development of skills in comparative legal analysis, legal reasoning, and the practical application of constitutional procedural law.
